Sir mn history k bary mn kch ni janta bs ik bat jo Mr Sajid Shah ne kahi us k response mn kahon ga unho ne kaha Yazeed Waq e karbla mn be qasoor tha. mn en se pochon ga kia Hakim e waqt pe kisi k jano maal ki hifazat farz ni? agr ap ka jwab ni mn hy to jo zulam aj ho rha us k khilaf awaz buland kijiye ta k kal koi ap jaisa phr tareekh ko na jhutlaa skay
1. Pervaiz Musharaf pe Be Nazeer qatal case q chlaya gia r apki supreme court ne usy saza q sunai?
2. karachi mn Rangers k hatho qatal k badly mn apki Supreme cort ne D.I.G rangers aur I.G sindh ko ber trf (hatany) ka hukam q dia????????
nadeem ahmed butt
janab ch sb hasbe mamool ki tahrna aap niy try ki hy samjhany ki lekin hum bhi itny pagal nhi kay aap ki baaten itni jaldi samjay aap try jaree rakhe Allah aap ko kamyab kary
o shoaib g sayedna hazret e hussain ke shahadet ka moqy py badla howa tha r ap k qatil jin ke tadad 60 the un mardoodon ko yazeed ke sipah ny moqy py he mar deya tha r ya sary kofi thy,apni islah k lya daikhya tareekh ibn e khaladun, ibn e sad,baqi ap ko to bari fikar ha k hakim ke zimadari the?pr hazret hussain k janasheen janab zainuabidin r sayda zainb ny ya kyon na kaha k yazeed zimadar ha ?kisi aik b khutby ma yazeed ka name ne lya blky kaha k koofi zimadar hain r majalisalmomineen ma likha ha qazi noorullaha ny k koffi sary shia thy,apna tareekhi record drust farmaen nabi saws ny farmaya sb sy bather maira qarn yani maira zamana ha qarn 120 sal ka hota ha ap sab sy achy zamany k sath sab sy bury waqiayt gharh ray hain qayamet ko nabi saws ka samna b krna ha musilman tareekh ka mutalya kren shia tareekh ka ne?
kashif nadeem
Sajid Shah bhai kon sahi tha kon ghalat tha iska faisla hum r app kernay walay kon hotay hain yea qudrat hi faisla kerti hay izat or Zillat Allah k hi ikhtyar main hay waqay Karbala k bad say or ajj tak Imam Hussain (A.S) ka jo maqam hay wo sab jantay hain jabkay yazed ko ajj koi bhi achay word main yaad nahi kerta yazeed ka nam suntay hi zehan main ek zalim insan ki shabi ban jati hay i m sure k app kisso ko bhi yazeed k nam say nahi mukhatib karan gay r na hi kabhi apni olad ka nam yazeed rakhain gay
Syed Ali Naqvi
جہاں تک امام سجاد علیہ السلام کی زندگی کا میں نے مطالعہ کیا ہے اور میری یادداشت کا سوال ہے مجھے حضرت (ع) کی زندگی میں کوئی ایک موقع بھی ایسا نہ مل سکا جہاں حکومت سے آپ (ع) نے اس طرح سے صریحی طور پر تعرض کیا ہو جیسا کہ دیگر ائمہ علیہم السلام مثلا بنی امیہ کے دور میں امام جعفر صادق علیہ السلام یا بعد میں امام موسیٰ کاظم علیہ السلام کے یہاں نظر آتا ہے ۔اور اس کی وجہ بھی ظاہر ہے کیوں کہ ائمہ معصومین علیہم اسلام کی امامت اور سیاسی تحریک کے وہ چار ادوار جس کے تیسرے مرحلہ کا آغاز امام زین العابدین علیہ السلام کی زندگی سے ہوتا ہے اگر اسی مرحلہ میں خلافت سے تعرض کی تحریک شروع کردی جاتی تو پورے وثوق سے کہا جا سکتا ہے کہ خطروں سے معمور ذمہ داریوں کا یہ کارواں ، اہل بیت علیہم السلام جس منزل تک لے جانا چاہتے تھے نہیں پہنچ سکتا تھا وہ گلستان اہلبیت (ع) جس کی تربیت و آبیاری امام سجاد علیہ السلام جیسے ماہرانہ صلاحیت کا حامل باغباں کر رہا تھا ،ابھی اتنا زیادہ مستحکم اور پائدار نہیں ہو سکتا تھا اس باغ میں ایسے نورس نونہال بھی موجود تھے جن میں طوفانی جھکڑوں سے مقابلہ کرنے کی طاقت ابھی پیدا نہیں ہوئی تھی ۔ جیسا کہ ہم اس بحث کے آغاز میں اشارہ کر چکے ہیں ،امام علیہ السلام کے گردو پیش اہلبیت (ع) سے محبت و عقیدت رکھنے والے مومنین کی بہت ہی مختصر سی تعداد تھی اور اس زمانے میں ممکن نہیں تھا کہ اس قلیل تعداد کو جس کے کاندھوں پر شیعی تنظیم کو چلانے کی عظیم ذمہ داری بھی ہے ظالم تھپیڑوں کے حوالے کر کے ان کو موت کے گھاٹ اتر جانے پر مجبور کر دیں
Syed Ali Naqvi
اگر تشبیہ دینا چاہیں تو امام زین العابدین علیہ السلام کے دور کی مکہ میں پیغمبر اسلام (ص) کی دعوت کے ابتدائی دور سے تشبیہ دی جا سکتی ہے یعنی دعوت اسلام کے وہ چند ابتدائی سال جب علی الاعلان دعوت دینا بھی ممکن نہ تھا ۔اسی طرح شاید امام محمد باقر علیہ السلام کے دور کی پیغمبر (ص) کی مکی تبلیغ کے دوسرے دور اور پھر اس کے ادوار کی دعوت اسلام کے بعد کے ادوار سے تشبیہ غلط نہ ہوگی ۔ لہٰذا تعرض اور مڈ بھیڑ کی حکمت عملی ابھی صحیح طور پر انجام نہ پاتی۔
یقین جانئے اگر وہی تیز و تند حکمت عملی ،جو امام صادق علیہ السلام ،امام کاظم علیہ السلام اور امام رضا علیہ السلام کے بعض کلمات سے مترشح ہوتی ہے ،امام سجاد علیہ السلام بھی اپنا لیتے تو عبد الملک بن مروان جس کا اقتدار پورے اوج پر نظر آتا ہے ،بڑی آسانی کے ساتھ تعلیمات اہلبیت (ع) کی پوری بساط الٹ کر رکھ دیتا اور پھر کام ایک نئے سرے سے شروع کرنا پڑتا اور یہ اقدام عاقلانہ نہ ہوتا ۔
اس کے باوجود امام زین العابدین علیہ السلام کے ارشادات و اقوال میں ،جو غالبا آپ کی زندگی اور طویل دور امامت کے آخر ی دنوں سے مربوط ہیں ،کہیں کہیں حکومتی مشینری کے ساتھ تعرض و مخالفت کے اشارے بھی مل جاتے ہیں
Syed Ali Naqvi
Sajid shah and to all…
1.Tareekhi shawahid k mtabiq yazeed hargiz deendar shakhs nhi ta apne baap ki zindigi ma bh islami usolon ko kabil itna nhi smjhta ta,
2. is ne apni 3 sala hakumat k doran tabahi,barbadi aur juraim ka irtaqab kia jis ki misaal tarikh islam ma nhi milti.
3. is ne kakumat k pehle sal imam hussain(nawasa-e-rasool)onki olaad o ashaab ko karbala ma bhooka piyasa berehmi k saath shaheed ker dia.mastorat ko qaid ker lia aur saron ko nezon pe buland kr bazaron shehron ma ghumaya.
4.apni kakumt k dosray sal is ne madina ma qatal aam kia jin ma ashaab bi thay, logon ki jan o mal o namoos to 3 din tk apni fouj per mubah kr dya.
5.hakumt k 3rd saal khana kaaba ko viraan kia aur aag laga di yeh hain yazid ibne muwiah k wo numaya karnamay jinhe anjam dene k liye mawiah ne ise khilafat ka libas pehnaya.
kashif nadeem g poury arab ma lakhon logon k name ap ko yazeed btla dun ga ap ke maloomat 0 ha mashoor soofi bazurg ba yazeed bustami ka name suna ha na?islami tareekh ma bot sari bari shakhsyat ka name yazeed milty hain ap ny islam usy samj rakha ha jo shia din kahalata ha wo islam ne ha islam sy mutasadm aik movment ha ap uski bt ny kren islam r musilmanon ke bt kren
Syed Ali Naqvi
agr tashaiyo ki sari tarikh mai yha likh don tou aap ko pata chal jai ga kon kitna “musalman” tha….kon haq per tha aur kon islam se mutsadim tha…sab jante hain tarkih ma kia hoa, mera behas ka mozu filhal yazid ko culprit sabit kerna tha tarikh se…aap se zaati koi larai nhi hai, aap apna deen pe chalo agr tashaiyo ko islam se mutsadim kaho gay, tou hum chup nhi rhen gay, phir sab k chehre se nikab utr jai ga.
naqvi saib jahan daleel khatam ho jy wahan ghosa aa jaya krta ha koe bt ne ap apna ghosa thookya g bt daleel ke ho rai ap ko keyon tap charh gae ha?tens mat lain g ap mujy facebook pr b ml sakty hain bt daleel ke ha ma ny to shoib sb sy bt ke r apni daleel di ha ap kyon nraz ho gy daleel ka jawab na ho to khamoshi bater ha ya ghosa r gali gloch kamzoori ke alamt hoti ha g sonyo
Hamid shah
I am agree with u sajid shah sb….karbala ki tareekh waqiay k kafi arsay bhad likhi gai hai aur tamam ki tamam oper nechay hai…..
Usman Baig
Sajid Shah Sb ki baat me dam hai. Aur Ahle Tashee ke apnay nazriat hain aou ahle sunat ke apnay. Humara manna hai ke Islam badshahat nahin chahta keh baap ke baad beta hi badshah banay tabhi Hazorr (SAW) ne apnay baad apna janasheen namzad nahin kia. Ahle tashee kehtay hain ke Hazrat Ali (RA) aur un ki Aulad (RA) ka khilafat per haq tha. Agar yeh baat darust hai tou Hazrat Ali (RA) se ziada Shuja aur bahadur kon ho ga. Aur agar unhoon ne baqi Khulfa (RA) ke daur e Khilafat main ye Haq nahin jatlaya tou Ahle Tashee ye haq jatlanay per kyoun bazid hain? Is ka matlab hai ke aahle Tashee Hazrat Ali (RA) ki rai se ikhtelaf kar rahe hain. Sajid Shah sb apna email batain take aap se rabta ho sakay.
usman baig saib ap mujy facebook pr mil sakty hain maira adress ha multani allama. ya phr ap mujy yahan e mail kren,[email protected] r ap chaen to skype pr b bt kr sakty hain wahan b maira adress ha,multani group
M.AKRAM NIAZI
Javed Choudhary Sahab their is need to use these instincts of human beings in positive direction.
Man should earn money by serving others like Bill Gates and not by corruption like Zardari
Man should gain power and prosperity by doing good deeds like Hazrat Umar and not murdering innocent people like Changez Khan
Man should make palaces but with honestly earned money like common people and not by stolen money like Surray Palace of Benazir.
All these things should be done then these desires and wishes are great but if done by using unfair means then a nuisance and a curse.
I m much grieved,when I have gone to the history of Islam.There r no words to express my feelings
mustfa
javid sahib aap n kamal ki history bayan ki u r great.And carry on
Syed Ali Naqvi
ma ne tou kisi ko gali nhi di jhota ilzaam q lagate ho?
jo log yazid ko RA kehte hon on ko kia dalil di ja sakti hai?
usman baig bahral apke juwab ye rha: shia mutadi qurani ayat aur Anhazrat(s.a.w.w) ki ahadis ki rohni ma hazrat Ali ko rasool akram ki rehlat k baad islam ka peshwa, imam, janisheen, khalifa aur haqiqi wasris mante hain, dawat zul-ashira mai jab aap ne apni baaset ka maqsad biyan kia aur aqarba se mada talab ki aur kaha k jo meri mada kre ga wo mera bhai, khalifa aur janisheen ho ga hazrat ali ne aap ki madad ka wada kia aur apne is ahed ko badar, ohad, khandaq aur dosre moqon per ba ahsan ajnam dia aur akhri hajj ka moqa per Rasool Allah ne hukam khuda k mutabiq gadeer k maidan ma tamam hajjaj k samne hazrat Ali ki khilafat aur wilayat k elaan kia, lehaza hazrat Ali ki khilafat k elaan khud Rasool Allah ne kia hai “mun kuntu moula fahaza Ali un moula” yeh hadis shia aur ahle sunat k nazdik muslma hadis ma se hai aur 100 se ziada ashab asnaad aur abarat k saat nakal kia hai (ref: Gayat al-maram/ 79)
mera aap se aik suwal hai: jab Rasool Allah madina se bahir jate thay tou kisi sahabi ko apna janisheen bna k jate ty, kia yeh mumkin hai aap dunya se jain aur ummat k liye koi janeshin na bna kr jain???
bht si ayat aur ruwayat is baat per dalil hain Rasool Akram ne apna janshin khud apni hayat ma muqar farmaya hargiz is ahim amr ko ummat k hawaly nhi kia. guzishta ambia ki zindiyon ka mutalia krne k baad ye bat wazha hojati ha k on ki ummaton ne kabhi onka janshin muqar nhi kia tha, khud ambia khuda k hukum se apna janshin muqarar kerte ty “hamare nabi pak ki ummat ko yeh haq kese mil gya” jabke nabi pak ne apni zindagi k shru ma (dwt zul ashira) aur akhir ma (ghadir khum) ma apne wasi ka elaan kr dia tha,
Rasool Akram: har nabi ka aik waris aur janishin hai aur mera janshin o waris Ali ibne abi talin A.S hain. in dalail ki roshni ma kisi ummati ko ye haq hasil nhi k woh nabi ka waris muqarar kre bus shia nabi pak k baad hazrt Ali aur onke farzando ko islam ka peshwa mante hain jin ki pehchan khud nabi pak ne krwai hai.
wah g wah sadqy jawan pr hath na lawan sonyo,,maira pala sawal k ya bt wasyat e khilafat ya imamat e ali rz sirf apko pta ha ya hazret ali rz ko b pta the?agr pta the to khilafat uno ny keyon na le r kholafaa e salasa k dor ma qaziuqoza keyon bny ray?ap k mutabiq baqi logon nyjan booj k sayedna muhammadurasoolullah ke waseyat pr amal ne kya r unen khilaft nae de?to dr saib ya b to btaen hazret ali kyon khamosh ry tareek keyon ne cahalaae?rayaset k aahm ohodon pr faez kyon ry? sirf sawalon ka jawab de jya r muqararana andaz ma de jya koe thos waja bata sakty hain k hazret ali ny aisa kyon kya yaninabi ke wasyat k mutabiq uno ny apna haq kyon ne lya?
Nek Akhtar
We regard you much because we are impressed by your research side in your writings but the other day i was startled to see that you follwed Hindus in your article by saying that Mehmood of Ghazna looted gold and copper. He was not a dacoit that you wrote or Hindus say that he looted their country. Actually he brought with him all those things after he conquerered the areas as Maal e ghaneemat. you have lacerated us by writing one of the great iconoclast of Islam a Looter. You must apologize for your words if you are a man of manner.
Regards
Nek Akhtar
Hamid shah
Sajid sab yeh naqvi sb k pas koi daleel nai hai apnay say man gharat hawalay day rhy hain aur koi thos daleel nai paish kar rhy wesay he ummat ko pagel banaya hoa hai….deen k huliya he beghara hoa hai….Qalma Change kia hoa hai… Namaz change ki hoi hai…aur phr kehtay hain humin non-muslim na kaho……
Syed Ali Naqvi
teri sadgai pe qurban jaon ai mulla je,
apki baat sehi hai moula Ali agr chahte tou akele hi kafi thay on sab k liye aur apna haq talwar k zor se wasul ker skte thay, per kese aisi hakumat k liye talwar utha sakte thay moula Ali kyun k aap jante thay k yeh log abhi naye musalman hoay hain aur mere is iqdaam se ummat kahin dobara apni pechli halat ma na chali jai, eik waja tou yeh thi. moula Ali jante thay agr jang ki gai tou nouzaida ummat musalma ultay paon na phir jai,
is ki misal ma apko moula Ali aur hazrat umar k dor k waqiya se sunata hun, darbar ma 2 aurton k darmeyan 1 bache k mamle mai jhagra ho gya aik kehti mera hai dosri kehti mera hai khalifa k liye faisla bht mushkil ho rha tha, aise ma moula Ali ki madad talb ki gai, aap ne kha talwar lao aur bacha k 2 hise ker k dono aurton ko aik aik de do, ye suna tha k jis aurat ka woh bacha tha os ka rang zard par gya aur boli k is ko maro mat ye bacha dosri aurat ko de do, yeh zinda tou rhay ga, mere pas na sehi meri ankhon k samne tou rhay ga, moula Ali ne jab yeh dekha tou sab per yeh sabit ho gya k yehi aurat bache ki haqiqi maa thi jab k dosri aurat kh b na boli,
is misal aap samajh jain Rasool Allah ki rehlat k foran baad hi khilafat k liye “ASHAAB” ne saqifaa (rendezvous)ma plan shru kr diya k khilafat ko qabo kro, jab moula Ali aur ahl-e-bait aur onke sachay ashaab Rasool Allah k kafan dafan mai lage hoay thay, aur baki Ashaab ko khilafat ki pari hoi thi, jo Rasol k yaar-e-ghar b thay…LEKIN AFSOS YAR NE APNE YAR KA JANAZA B NA PARHA…
kuch suwal muje b kerne ka haq hai. wese mulla je yeh tou batao Rasool pak s.a.w.w k janaze mai kitne musalman sharik thay???
Syed Ali Naqvi
@Hamid shah, Title “shia” Quran o Hadith ma majood hai Hazrat Ibrahim (as) ko shia naam le ker pukara gya hai, kia tum ise mante ho?
Syed Ali Naqvi
Term “Shia” Asal ma Quran se akhaz ki gai hai is ka actual origin Quran se hai, jis ma Allah ne Ibrahim nabi(as)ko hazrat NUh(as) ka shia kaha hai, aik aur ayt ma 2 admiyo ki larai ka zikr hai jis ma aik Musa(as) ka “shia” tha aur dosra on ka dushman.
1. The Holy Qur’an 37:83
2. The Holy Qur’an 28:15
asal ma logon ko bewekof tou aap logo ne bnaya hoa hai
sadqy g,,,ap ny mairy sawal k jawab ma jo likha ha wo jawab to ne g?phr b ap choonky molaun k hily howy hain maff krna ma molviat sy qoson door bagta hun chalen ap ny jo jawab likha ha iske koe dalil dy dain kaya hazret ali rz ny ya bt kb kahi the kisi kitab sy hawala dy dain ya phr kahen sy b na mily to nahjulbalagha to hazret ali rz k khutbat ka majmoua ha wahan sy dikha dain,ya ilfaz ap sabit kr dain kisi kitab sy k hazret ali rz ny kaha ho k ma khilafet ly sakyta tha pr is waja sy ne lee,agr un sy na mily to hazret hassan rz sy sabit kr do un sy ne hazret hussain rz sy un sy ne zianulabidin sy un sy ne to jafar sadiq sy,imama baqir sy,ali naqi sy,taqi ali sy,mousa kazim sy ,hussan askari sy apny 12 imamon ma sy kisi ka hawala dy kr ya lafz sabt kro k ma khilafat ly sakta tagha maira haq tha pr is waja sy ne lee agr sabit na ho saky r yaqeenan ne to janab ny imam e adil o barhaq fateh khaiber,qatil e marhab shair e khoda ,damad e mustafa as,sayedna ali ul murtaza rz pr jhoot bandah ha bs ya he ibtada ha ap k ghalt moaquf ke pr etyat sy keyon k ap aik mulan ko ne aik aam musilman ko dalil dy ry hain jo ap k din pr iran ma sarkari sata k muqalmon ma hisa ly choka ha
jan ke amaan paun to arz kr sakta hun ap ny hamid shah ko b jawab sahe ne deya sheia katy hain groh ko quran ma aya ha k tum un logon ke tra na ho jana jino ny firqy paida kya r sheia ho gy .kaya is sy murad b ap ka groh he ha?
Syed Ali Naqvi
Itminaan rakhe sab suwalon k juwab do ga apko per aik shart per wo yeh kmai b aap se kuch suwal karon ga, is trah aap guftago ko mazeed uljha rhai hain,
Dekhye nahj-ul-balagha utha ker ‘
imam farmate han yeh 25 saal (pehle 3 khulfa ka door) mere liye is trha thay jaise galley ma phansi hoi haddi jisse na nigal sako aur na ugal sake, ye aik chota sa hawala hai, aur is khutba ka naam “khutba shakshakia” hai arbi ma hai agr aap nehjul balaga se waqfiyat rekhte hain tou dekh lain utha k khud hi,ya postel address dain ma courier kra do ga. mazeed bi hawla dia ja sakta hai, Mashallah aap tou sarkari satah k munazir hain, but bakhuda ma aik aam se student hun jis ne abhi graduation kia hai mai bi koi molvi nhi.
Syed Ali Naqvi
dekhye janab shia ka matlab hai pervi krene wala, kisi k peche chalne wala, ” maslan tashi-e-janaza” lafz suna hai na aap ne yani janaze k peche chalna, ye jo tabir aap bata rhay ho ghalat hai. dekye suwal woh karen jo logical ho plz
chalen g aik bt to ty ho gai k kal ap ny jo ilfaz hazret ali rz ke traf mansoob kya thy wo maazallaha un ke zat e grami pr janab ke traf sy botan tha,inalillahaewaainaelaierajeuun,,,,ya apny ilfaz sabit kren k khilafat maira haq tha r ma ly sakta tha pr is waja sy ne lee jo waja janab ny bayan ke ha?ap ny jo hawala dya ha us pr ma dalil bd ma dun ga ap ny bybunyad hawala paly dya ha lehaza ap jawab b paly dain,,r agr ap wo ilfaz jo ap ny imam e masoom ke trf mansoob kya hain wo na dikhayy kisi khutby sy to janab ko ma qabil e taqalum ne samjta,,,2ousri bt ap ny aaj to likh dya k shia k matlib pervi krna ha zra apny kl k ilfaz daikhen ap ny likha tha k shia k lafz quran sy lya gya ha jis pr ap ny dalil b di k musa as ka shia r ibraim as,ma ny ap ko quran sy btaya k jahan lafz shia ha wahan sy agr ap he murad hain to,,,un logon ke tra na ho jana jino ne farqy paida kya r shia ho gy,,,ya ma ny quran ka hawala dya ha r ap ny kah dya k ya ghalat ha waja bta sakty hain keyon ghalat ha?r agli bt b sunen kl ap ny lafz e shia py jo comments dya thy aaj ap k wo comments ne hain ap apni bt sy istra phisal gy hain jistra molvi…….theak ha g lagy rao lagy rao pr jo ilfaz ap ny imam e masoom ke traf mansoob kya hain wo sabit kr do?ne to phr bt wo he ha paly wali jo ap ko b pta ha?
lagta ha ma b shooka itmanan rakh k he baith jaun kyon k jawab to ha he ne ab ay ga kahan sy waisy ap k ilm ma ezafa kr dun apni kitaben zroor praha kren baly musilmano ke na b paren pr apni to paren ap ke kitaben,kafikuleni,alirshad shaikh mufeed,alamuwaraa,,kashfulghuma arbali,maroujhzahb masoodi,muntaalamaal mirza abas qumi,,hayat ul qaloob mula baqir majlasi in tamam kutab ma likha ha k hazret ali rz sayedna abubakar sadiq rz k dor e khilafet ma qazi ul quzaa k mansab pr ry,,kaya hazret ali ny ghasib hakoomat ka hoda qabool kya tha? dil bara kren r aaj he beharulanwar,muntaalmaqal r muntaalamaal b daikh lain pouchaa gya imam e masoom sy ap ny abubakr ke bait kb ke?jawab dya k ALLAHA R RASOOL K HUKAM KE TAMEEL KE HA….ap ke zat e garami k laya doa he kr sakta hun k khoda tujy kisi tufan sy ashnaa kry ….k tery baher ke mojon ma iztarab ne….ab ap apni books ka inkar kr dain ya koe looli langri taweel paish kren ne to bt wo he ha paly wali r ap ko b pta he ha
allama shibli nomani ny alintaqad ma likha ha k khoda ke qasam hajaj ny islam k haq ma itni bari bahlaaee ke k iska muqabla ho he ne sakta
===========
Allama Shibli Nomani ny Apni Book Al-Farooq Main, Hadhrat Umar Farooq (RA) ky bary main Hadhrat Fatima (SA) ky Saath jo Kuch Kiya Chalo wo tou Maan Hi Lo Ap…
@Hajjaj Bin Yousuf ky barRy main Allama Moudoudi ki Kitab hi Parh lyn, He Worte ky, Aik Achy Insaan ka Qatl ka, Aik Insaan ki 1,000 Nekiyon ky Barabar nahi ho sakta hai…
Aur Qatl bhi Kin ka, Hadhrat Abdullah Ibn Zubair (RA) Jaisey Sahabi Aur Kaaba per Sang BarRi…
Aur Rahee Baat yazid (LA) ko Support krny ki tou Ahmed Ibn Hanble, Tarikh Tabari Sy ley kr Ibn Kathir ki book, Tarikh Ibn Kathir Parh Lo….
yazid tou phir bhi aik bacha tou Jo yazid ky Walid ny Hadhrat Ali (AS) ko Gaaliyan Di Aur Hadhrat Hassan (AS) ko Zahr Dilwaya, ye Sab kuch Tarikh Ibn Kathir main hai Jao Parho.
Allama Jalaal Ud Din Suyti ki book hi parh lo Ap yazid ky liay Tarikh E Khulfa.
Syed Ali Naqvi
” chalo tum ne imam-e-masoom tou mana moula Ali (as)ko tmri zuban se yeh ilfaz tou nikle jazakallah…wah bai wah dekhen aap jeteay mai hara meri trf se tohfa hai apko 🙂
ma ne koi hawala nhi diya logic se baat ki aur misal de elaborate bi kia tha,
“khilafat maira haq tha r ma ly sakta tha pr”….ye ilfaz mere hain moula Ali k nhi… is k hawala k peche na paro
Syed Ali Naqvi
Amongst the companions Hadhrath Abu Bakr is viewed as the most superior on account of his closeness to the Holy Prophet (saaws). If this is indeed the case then why did the Holy Prophet (saaws) not select him to be his brother when he (saaws) divided the companions in to pairs on the Day of Brotherhood? Rather, the Prophet (saaws) chose Hadhrath Ali (as) saying “You are my brother in this world and the next”, so on what basis is Hadhrath Abu Bakr closer?
See The History of the Khalifahs who took the right way, by Jalaladeen Suyuti,
sahaba ma se abu bakar ko baki ashab se bartari hasil ha k wo Hazoor k bht qareeb ty,agr waqai asa hai tou Hazoor ne abu bakar ko q apna bhai na bnaya (on the day of brotherhood) jabke Hazoor pak ne Ali as ko apna bhai bnaya “aur farmaya Ay Ali tum is dunya mai aur agli dunya ma b mere bhai ho” kis bina per abu bakar ko fazilat hasil hai? dekhain , tarik-e-khulafa by jalaladeen suyuti
Syed Ali Naqvi
khilafat maira haq tha r ma ly sakta tha pr….yeh ilfaz ma ne hazrat Ali k nhi qoute kiye thay, aur na hi ma ne ma yeh ilfaz likhe hain apne comment main, jo ma ne likha woh yeh hai,
(apki baat sehi hai moula Ali agr chahte tou akele hi kafi thay on sab k liye aur apna haq talwar k zor se wasul ker skte thay, per kese aisi hakumat k liye talwar utha sakte thay moula Ali kyun k aap jante thay k yeh log abhi naye musalman hoay hain aur mere is iqdaam se ummat kahin dobara apni pechli halat ma na chali jai, eik waja tou yeh thi. moula Ali jante thay agr jang ki gai tou nouzaida ummat musalma ultay paon na phir jai,)
Agr hazrat Ali 3 khulafa k door ma aham ehdon per faiz rhy, tu ono ne kisi bi jang ma hissa Kyun na liya jo k khulafa k door ma lari gayin? koi tarikh k hawalah hai aapke paas!! khas tor per jihad kufar k khilaf hr musalman per wajib hai…is k baraks Hazrat Ali ne apne door me 50 saal ki umar mai Nehrawan, siffeen o jamal larin?
ap agr itny he zbardast tareekh dan hain gardeezi g to ma ny ali naqvi ko janab k mahzeb ke motabr bokks k hawaly dya hain r ap ke kutab k hawaly kyon dy ra hun uski b waja saf zahir ha k ap un kitabon k elawa dunyan ma r kisi ktab ko manty he ne ab jo mazhb quran pr b kamil emaan na rakhta ho zahir ha wo mahzhb to na howa din howa r jb din howa to phr bt wo he ha ply wali jo ap ko achi tra pta ha waisy akhlaqi tor par ap ko chaya tha ap us nukty pr bt krty k ap k momin bi ny hupr ke guftaguu ma imam e masoom ke traf jhoot banda ha paly uska jawab dain jo k mujy 7 dafa qum k sarkari debates ma b ne mila ap kaya dain gy raty rataay jumly,bybunyad guftaguu,mangharat stories,laayani qisy,bani hoe rawaeten na paishbkren,,ya jo ap hazret ali rz r sayedna ameer e muawiya rz ka ikhtalif byan kr ray hain ya quran ka inkar ha,,apny mahzb k allama kashi ke rijall ka mutalya kren ap k 2 imamon r aik un k commander inchief ny un ke bait ke the,kaya koe aj ka molvi mimber py baith k ap k abu g ko galyan dy phr ap ko kahy mairee bait kro ap kr lo gy?r ap husnain karimain rz ko kis hd tk ly k ja ry hain k uno ny us ke bait ke jo mimber sy galyan daita tha un k walid garami ko ya rijal kashi ka inkar karen ya jhooty qisy chor dain nae to bt wo he ha paly wali r ap ko b pta ha
ap ko alf baa ka b pata ne g paly kaen parh lain phr bt karna ma ny imam e masoom naqs kya ha ma ap ke bt ka kjawab ilzaman dy ra hun ap mafhoom e mukhalif samj gy hahahahahaha sadqy jawan ap ny man lya na k wo ilfaz mairy thy hazret ali k ne? bs phr bt wo he ha jo ap ko paly sy pata ha ma na b btaun to b?
bat wo he hoe na ap ny dobara b wo he ilfaz likhy hain k ma agr talwar uthata ya jang krta to ya nuqsan hota is lya khamosh ra naqvi g ya ilfaz ap k zehn k ikhtarah ha ya ilfaz hazret ali rz k ne ap kyon un ke trf apny jhooty khayalaat ko mansoob krny py baa zid hain ya to hawala paish kren ma ny to allama kashi ke rijaal ka hawala dya ha k hazret ali rz qazi ul quzaa k mansab pr ray ap kah dain k ya ktab hamari nae ha?ya ap allama kashi ka inkar kren ya ap jurat kren r kah dain k hazret ali rz bura b samjty thy pr wazarten b laity thy?apny moaquf pr motahbr hawala dain r allama kashi k hawaly ka jawab dain ma to ap ke kitabon sy bt kr ra hun ma ny quran o hadis ke to bt he ne ke kyon k ap na quran ko manty ho na nabi saws k frman ko agr apni kitaben he parh lo phr b bt ho sakti ha ,,,,un he k matlab ke kah ra hun zaban mairee ha bat un kee….un he ke mahfil sanwarta hun charagh maira ha rat un ke,,,hahahahafil waqt ap r ap ka hawala zer e bas ha ap is pr bt kren agr ha to r agr ne to bt wo he ha paly wali jon ap ko b pata ha?
Syed Ali Naqvi
os kitaab ka reference pora do: reference includes 1.Writer 2.volume 3.page no. jese ma oper de chuka hoon apki kitabon se
ap ke apni motabar r mashoor books k bary ma b maloomat 0 ha sono ma page numb b bta daita hun pr agr wahan sy b maira moaquf sabit ho jy to phr?allama kashi 3rd century ka mustanad shia alim ha uski kitab ha rijal kashi,hussnain kareemain rz r unky commander incheif qias rz ny saydna ameer e muawiya ke na sirf bait ke blky frmaya k ap he hamary bather imam hain,,,,ap ko apni kitab ka name r imam he pta ne?mothrem ap k 2 imam jisy apna imam kah ry hain wo ap k baqole mimber pr baith k hazret ali rz ko naoozbillah galyan daita tha ap k 2 masoomeen aur 1 com ny bait kyon ke wja wo bayan krna jo ap k 2 ono imamon ny bayan ke ho apna khayal paish na krna r agr waja b na mily bait b sabit ho ap ke books sy waz\ifa laina b sabit ho to phr bat wo he ha jo ap ko pta ha mujy kany ke zroorat ne
liaquat.qureshi
javed chodri saib ap ne tareekh ka mutaliah nehi kia
Tahseen Ghani
Wah bara khoobsorat mazmoon hey laikin aalamgeer aur mehmood Ghazanvi ki Misal kuch theek nahen kion ke Aalm Geer taqreeban 52 saal hakoomat kerta raha aur Mehmood Ghazanvi ney Islami hakoomat ki bunyaad rakhi.
ya zamana andhi taqleed ka ne,taqeeq justajuu r haqaiq janany ka zamana ha mujy yaqeen ha naqvi sb ap daleel k samny aajiz aa gy hain akhlaqi tor par ap ko phr sy apny din pr nazarsani krni chaya inshallah ap is nateejy pr ponchen gy k shia din hazret ali rz sy ly kr husnain kareemain rzsayda fatima rz khatoon e janat r hussan askari tk tamam hasteyon sy mutasadam r unky nazreyat k mukhalif ha agr ap siraat e mustaqeem qabool kr lain yani hazret ali rz ka haqiqi rasta to dunya akhrit ke kamyaabi ha r na kren to bat wo he ha jo ap ko paly sy pata ha mujy kahny ke zroorat ne
Azmat Ali Shah
Javed Bhai,you have compared good and bad in a very logical way.An evil deed does not give a permanent advantage to a man indulging in it.On the other hand,a good work can live for a longer period and the coming generations remember that deed with envy and admiration.Don’t you think it is a deficiency in our educated people or in our education system that ,majority of our people try to imitate bad people not good one.Also bad deeds are more attractive for their short term advantages than good works.It is something to ponder upon,we should follow long term advantage than short one.Our education system needs reforms to do something in this regard.
Ap bht acha likhty han ,i like your colmn,write and awake our nation.
Muhammad Asif
sultan Mehmood ki age 63 year thi
Naseem Hajazi ki book k mutabiq. sultan bot shikan tha lakin bot farosh nahi tha ap ne usy lalchi bhi kaha jo k ghalat hy.
wo aik naik insan tha us k baray main ap ye mat likho.
Aurangzaib k bary main bhi ap ne kuch aisa hi likha jo k ghalat hy. lagta hy k ap Muslims Heroes k mukhalif ho ap sirf musharaf or Zardari jaison k qabil ho. meri kisi bhi bat ka mind na karain plz.
rubaba ali
excellent, aise soch insan me a jay to dunya se zulam be khatam ho jayee
Rana jang sher
AOA,dear brother best wishes for you and your faimly.I like your colmn.
Usman Baig
Eik baat tou bohat hi wazih hai aur woh yeh keh Ahle Tashee tareekhi haqaiq ko hazam karna nahin chahte. Aur jo hazrat dunya se guzar chukay hain un per laan taan kar ke apne aap ko sirat e mustaqqem per samaghte hain.
umar
ch,sab ap ny bilkul baja farmaya.mein to samjhta hn ye or b lamha hy fikria hy hm in misalon sy ni seekhtay
saif ur rehman
ye isan ke fitrit man shamil ha dolitt ke hawas lakin ye sab kuch krnay se pahlay 1 baar in ko sochna chahe go oupr ravi ne likha ha insan ko nasehat zaror hasil hoti ha
Sir mn history k bary mn kch ni janta bs ik bat jo Mr Sajid Shah ne kahi us k response mn kahon ga unho ne kaha Yazeed Waq e karbla mn be qasoor tha. mn en se pochon ga kia Hakim e waqt pe kisi k jano maal ki hifazat farz ni? agr ap ka jwab ni mn hy to jo zulam aj ho rha us k khilaf awaz buland kijiye ta k kal koi ap jaisa phr tareekh ko na jhutlaa skay
1. Pervaiz Musharaf pe Be Nazeer qatal case q chlaya gia r apki supreme court ne usy saza q sunai?
2. karachi mn Rangers k hatho qatal k badly mn apki Supreme cort ne D.I.G rangers aur I.G sindh ko ber trf (hatany) ka hukam q dia????????
janab ch sb hasbe mamool ki tahrna aap niy try ki hy samjhany ki lekin hum bhi itny pagal nhi kay aap ki baaten itni jaldi samjay aap try jaree rakhe Allah aap ko kamyab kary
o shoaib g sayedna hazret e hussain ke shahadet ka moqy py badla howa tha r ap k qatil jin ke tadad 60 the un mardoodon ko yazeed ke sipah ny moqy py he mar deya tha r ya sary kofi thy,apni islah k lya daikhya tareekh ibn e khaladun, ibn e sad,baqi ap ko to bari fikar ha k hakim ke zimadari the?pr hazret hussain k janasheen janab zainuabidin r sayda zainb ny ya kyon na kaha k yazeed zimadar ha ?kisi aik b khutby ma yazeed ka name ne lya blky kaha k koofi zimadar hain r majalisalmomineen ma likha ha qazi noorullaha ny k koffi sary shia thy,apna tareekhi record drust farmaen nabi saws ny farmaya sb sy bather maira qarn yani maira zamana ha qarn 120 sal ka hota ha ap sab sy achy zamany k sath sab sy bury waqiayt gharh ray hain qayamet ko nabi saws ka samna b krna ha musilman tareekh ka mutalya kren shia tareekh ka ne?
Sajid Shah bhai kon sahi tha kon ghalat tha iska faisla hum r app kernay walay kon hotay hain yea qudrat hi faisla kerti hay izat or Zillat Allah k hi ikhtyar main hay waqay Karbala k bad say or ajj tak Imam Hussain (A.S) ka jo maqam hay wo sab jantay hain jabkay yazed ko ajj koi bhi achay word main yaad nahi kerta yazeed ka nam suntay hi zehan main ek zalim insan ki shabi ban jati hay i m sure k app kisso ko bhi yazeed k nam say nahi mukhatib karan gay r na hi kabhi apni olad ka nam yazeed rakhain gay
جہاں تک امام سجاد علیہ السلام کی زندگی کا میں نے مطالعہ کیا ہے اور میری یادداشت کا سوال ہے مجھے حضرت (ع) کی زندگی میں کوئی ایک موقع بھی ایسا نہ مل سکا جہاں حکومت سے آپ (ع) نے اس طرح سے صریحی طور پر تعرض کیا ہو جیسا کہ دیگر ائمہ علیہم السلام مثلا بنی امیہ کے دور میں امام جعفر صادق علیہ السلام یا بعد میں امام موسیٰ کاظم علیہ السلام کے یہاں نظر آتا ہے ۔اور اس کی وجہ بھی ظاہر ہے کیوں کہ ائمہ معصومین علیہم اسلام کی امامت اور سیاسی تحریک کے وہ چار ادوار جس کے تیسرے مرحلہ کا آغاز امام زین العابدین علیہ السلام کی زندگی سے ہوتا ہے اگر اسی مرحلہ میں خلافت سے تعرض کی تحریک شروع کردی جاتی تو پورے وثوق سے کہا جا سکتا ہے کہ خطروں سے معمور ذمہ داریوں کا یہ کارواں ، اہل بیت علیہم السلام جس منزل تک لے جانا چاہتے تھے نہیں پہنچ سکتا تھا وہ گلستان اہلبیت (ع) جس کی تربیت و آبیاری امام سجاد علیہ السلام جیسے ماہرانہ صلاحیت کا حامل باغباں کر رہا تھا ،ابھی اتنا زیادہ مستحکم اور پائدار نہیں ہو سکتا تھا اس باغ میں ایسے نورس نونہال بھی موجود تھے جن میں طوفانی جھکڑوں سے مقابلہ کرنے کی طاقت ابھی پیدا نہیں ہوئی تھی ۔ جیسا کہ ہم اس بحث کے آغاز میں اشارہ کر چکے ہیں ،امام علیہ السلام کے گردو پیش اہلبیت (ع) سے محبت و عقیدت رکھنے والے مومنین کی بہت ہی مختصر سی تعداد تھی اور اس زمانے میں ممکن نہیں تھا کہ اس قلیل تعداد کو جس کے کاندھوں پر شیعی تنظیم کو چلانے کی عظیم ذمہ داری بھی ہے ظالم تھپیڑوں کے حوالے کر کے ان کو موت کے گھاٹ اتر جانے پر مجبور کر دیں
اگر تشبیہ دینا چاہیں تو امام زین العابدین علیہ السلام کے دور کی مکہ میں پیغمبر اسلام (ص) کی دعوت کے ابتدائی دور سے تشبیہ دی جا سکتی ہے یعنی دعوت اسلام کے وہ چند ابتدائی سال جب علی الاعلان دعوت دینا بھی ممکن نہ تھا ۔اسی طرح شاید امام محمد باقر علیہ السلام کے دور کی پیغمبر (ص) کی مکی تبلیغ کے دوسرے دور اور پھر اس کے ادوار کی دعوت اسلام کے بعد کے ادوار سے تشبیہ غلط نہ ہوگی ۔ لہٰذا تعرض اور مڈ بھیڑ کی حکمت عملی ابھی صحیح طور پر انجام نہ پاتی۔
یقین جانئے اگر وہی تیز و تند حکمت عملی ،جو امام صادق علیہ السلام ،امام کاظم علیہ السلام اور امام رضا علیہ السلام کے بعض کلمات سے مترشح ہوتی ہے ،امام سجاد علیہ السلام بھی اپنا لیتے تو عبد الملک بن مروان جس کا اقتدار پورے اوج پر نظر آتا ہے ،بڑی آسانی کے ساتھ تعلیمات اہلبیت (ع) کی پوری بساط الٹ کر رکھ دیتا اور پھر کام ایک نئے سرے سے شروع کرنا پڑتا اور یہ اقدام عاقلانہ نہ ہوتا ۔
اس کے باوجود امام زین العابدین علیہ السلام کے ارشادات و اقوال میں ،جو غالبا آپ کی زندگی اور طویل دور امامت کے آخر ی دنوں سے مربوط ہیں ،کہیں کہیں حکومتی مشینری کے ساتھ تعرض و مخالفت کے اشارے بھی مل جاتے ہیں
Sajid shah and to all…
1.Tareekhi shawahid k mtabiq yazeed hargiz deendar shakhs nhi ta apne baap ki zindigi ma bh islami usolon ko kabil itna nhi smjhta ta,
2. is ne apni 3 sala hakumat k doran tabahi,barbadi aur juraim ka irtaqab kia jis ki misaal tarikh islam ma nhi milti.
3. is ne kakumat k pehle sal imam hussain(nawasa-e-rasool)onki olaad o ashaab ko karbala ma bhooka piyasa berehmi k saath shaheed ker dia.mastorat ko qaid ker lia aur saron ko nezon pe buland kr bazaron shehron ma ghumaya.
4.apni kakumt k dosray sal is ne madina ma qatal aam kia jin ma ashaab bi thay, logon ki jan o mal o namoos to 3 din tk apni fouj per mubah kr dya.
5.hakumt k 3rd saal khana kaaba ko viraan kia aur aag laga di yeh hain yazid ibne muwiah k wo numaya karnamay jinhe anjam dene k liye mawiah ne ise khilafat ka libas pehnaya.
References: (i)tarikh-e-yaqobi,(book-2 page 216)
(ii)tarikh abu al-fida (book-1 page190)
(iii)marvaj al-zahab(book-3 page 64)
kashif nadeem g poury arab ma lakhon logon k name ap ko yazeed btla dun ga ap ke maloomat 0 ha mashoor soofi bazurg ba yazeed bustami ka name suna ha na?islami tareekh ma bot sari bari shakhsyat ka name yazeed milty hain ap ny islam usy samj rakha ha jo shia din kahalata ha wo islam ne ha islam sy mutasadm aik movment ha ap uski bt ny kren islam r musilmanon ke bt kren
agr tashaiyo ki sari tarikh mai yha likh don tou aap ko pata chal jai ga kon kitna “musalman” tha….kon haq per tha aur kon islam se mutsadim tha…sab jante hain tarkih ma kia hoa, mera behas ka mozu filhal yazid ko culprit sabit kerna tha tarikh se…aap se zaati koi larai nhi hai, aap apna deen pe chalo agr tashaiyo ko islam se mutsadim kaho gay, tou hum chup nhi rhen gay, phir sab k chehre se nikab utr jai ga.
naqvi saib jahan daleel khatam ho jy wahan ghosa aa jaya krta ha koe bt ne ap apna ghosa thookya g bt daleel ke ho rai ap ko keyon tap charh gae ha?tens mat lain g ap mujy facebook pr b ml sakty hain bt daleel ke ha ma ny to shoib sb sy bt ke r apni daleel di ha ap kyon nraz ho gy daleel ka jawab na ho to khamoshi bater ha ya ghosa r gali gloch kamzoori ke alamt hoti ha g sonyo
I am agree with u sajid shah sb….karbala ki tareekh waqiay k kafi arsay bhad likhi gai hai aur tamam ki tamam oper nechay hai…..
Sajid Shah Sb ki baat me dam hai. Aur Ahle Tashee ke apnay nazriat hain aou ahle sunat ke apnay. Humara manna hai ke Islam badshahat nahin chahta keh baap ke baad beta hi badshah banay tabhi Hazorr (SAW) ne apnay baad apna janasheen namzad nahin kia. Ahle tashee kehtay hain ke Hazrat Ali (RA) aur un ki Aulad (RA) ka khilafat per haq tha. Agar yeh baat darust hai tou Hazrat Ali (RA) se ziada Shuja aur bahadur kon ho ga. Aur agar unhoon ne baqi Khulfa (RA) ke daur e Khilafat main ye Haq nahin jatlaya tou Ahle Tashee ye haq jatlanay per kyoun bazid hain? Is ka matlab hai ke aahle Tashee Hazrat Ali (RA) ki rai se ikhtelaf kar rahe hain. Sajid Shah sb apna email batain take aap se rabta ho sakay.
usman baig saib ap mujy facebook pr mil sakty hain maira adress ha multani allama. ya phr ap mujy yahan e mail kren,[email protected] r ap chaen to skype pr b bt kr sakty hain wahan b maira adress ha,multani group
Javed Choudhary Sahab their is need to use these instincts of human beings in positive direction.
Man should earn money by serving others like Bill Gates and not by corruption like Zardari
Man should gain power and prosperity by doing good deeds like Hazrat Umar and not murdering innocent people like Changez Khan
Man should make palaces but with honestly earned money like common people and not by stolen money like Surray Palace of Benazir.
All these things should be done then these desires and wishes are great but if done by using unfair means then a nuisance and a curse.
M.AKRAM KHAN NIAZI
I m much grieved,when I have gone to the history of Islam.There r no words to express my feelings
javid sahib aap n kamal ki history bayan ki u r great.And carry on
ma ne tou kisi ko gali nhi di jhota ilzaam q lagate ho?
jo log yazid ko RA kehte hon on ko kia dalil di ja sakti hai?
usman baig bahral apke juwab ye rha: shia mutadi qurani ayat aur Anhazrat(s.a.w.w) ki ahadis ki rohni ma hazrat Ali ko rasool akram ki rehlat k baad islam ka peshwa, imam, janisheen, khalifa aur haqiqi wasris mante hain, dawat zul-ashira mai jab aap ne apni baaset ka maqsad biyan kia aur aqarba se mada talab ki aur kaha k jo meri mada kre ga wo mera bhai, khalifa aur janisheen ho ga hazrat ali ne aap ki madad ka wada kia aur apne is ahed ko badar, ohad, khandaq aur dosre moqon per ba ahsan ajnam dia aur akhri hajj ka moqa per Rasool Allah ne hukam khuda k mutabiq gadeer k maidan ma tamam hajjaj k samne hazrat Ali ki khilafat aur wilayat k elaan kia, lehaza hazrat Ali ki khilafat k elaan khud Rasool Allah ne kia hai “mun kuntu moula fahaza Ali un moula” yeh hadis shia aur ahle sunat k nazdik muslma hadis ma se hai aur 100 se ziada ashab asnaad aur abarat k saat nakal kia hai (ref: Gayat al-maram/ 79)
mera aap se aik suwal hai: jab Rasool Allah madina se bahir jate thay tou kisi sahabi ko apna janisheen bna k jate ty, kia yeh mumkin hai aap dunya se jain aur ummat k liye koi janeshin na bna kr jain???
bht si ayat aur ruwayat is baat per dalil hain Rasool Akram ne apna janshin khud apni hayat ma muqar farmaya hargiz is ahim amr ko ummat k hawaly nhi kia. guzishta ambia ki zindiyon ka mutalia krne k baad ye bat wazha hojati ha k on ki ummaton ne kabhi onka janshin muqar nhi kia tha, khud ambia khuda k hukum se apna janshin muqarar kerte ty “hamare nabi pak ki ummat ko yeh haq kese mil gya” jabke nabi pak ne apni zindagi k shru ma (dwt zul ashira) aur akhir ma (ghadir khum) ma apne wasi ka elaan kr dia tha,
Rasool Akram: har nabi ka aik waris aur janishin hai aur mera janshin o waris Ali ibne abi talin A.S hain. in dalail ki roshni ma kisi ummati ko ye haq hasil nhi k woh nabi ka waris muqarar kre bus shia nabi pak k baad hazrt Ali aur onke farzando ko islam ka peshwa mante hain jin ki pehchan khud nabi pak ne krwai hai.
wah g wah sadqy jawan pr hath na lawan sonyo,,maira pala sawal k ya bt wasyat e khilafat ya imamat e ali rz sirf apko pta ha ya hazret ali rz ko b pta the?agr pta the to khilafat uno ny keyon na le r kholafaa e salasa k dor ma qaziuqoza keyon bny ray?ap k mutabiq baqi logon nyjan booj k sayedna muhammadurasoolullah ke waseyat pr amal ne kya r unen khilaft nae de?to dr saib ya b to btaen hazret ali kyon khamosh ry tareek keyon ne cahalaae?rayaset k aahm ohodon pr faez kyon ry? sirf sawalon ka jawab de jya r muqararana andaz ma de jya koe thos waja bata sakty hain k hazret ali ny aisa kyon kya yaninabi ke wasyat k mutabiq uno ny apna haq kyon ne lya?
We regard you much because we are impressed by your research side in your writings but the other day i was startled to see that you follwed Hindus in your article by saying that Mehmood of Ghazna looted gold and copper. He was not a dacoit that you wrote or Hindus say that he looted their country. Actually he brought with him all those things after he conquerered the areas as Maal e ghaneemat. you have lacerated us by writing one of the great iconoclast of Islam a Looter. You must apologize for your words if you are a man of manner.
Regards
Nek Akhtar
Sajid sab yeh naqvi sb k pas koi daleel nai hai apnay say man gharat hawalay day rhy hain aur koi thos daleel nai paish kar rhy wesay he ummat ko pagel banaya hoa hai….deen k huliya he beghara hoa hai….Qalma Change kia hoa hai… Namaz change ki hoi hai…aur phr kehtay hain humin non-muslim na kaho……
teri sadgai pe qurban jaon ai mulla je,
apki baat sehi hai moula Ali agr chahte tou akele hi kafi thay on sab k liye aur apna haq talwar k zor se wasul ker skte thay, per kese aisi hakumat k liye talwar utha sakte thay moula Ali kyun k aap jante thay k yeh log abhi naye musalman hoay hain aur mere is iqdaam se ummat kahin dobara apni pechli halat ma na chali jai, eik waja tou yeh thi. moula Ali jante thay agr jang ki gai tou nouzaida ummat musalma ultay paon na phir jai,
is ki misal ma apko moula Ali aur hazrat umar k dor k waqiya se sunata hun, darbar ma 2 aurton k darmeyan 1 bache k mamle mai jhagra ho gya aik kehti mera hai dosri kehti mera hai khalifa k liye faisla bht mushkil ho rha tha, aise ma moula Ali ki madad talb ki gai, aap ne kha talwar lao aur bacha k 2 hise ker k dono aurton ko aik aik de do, ye suna tha k jis aurat ka woh bacha tha os ka rang zard par gya aur boli k is ko maro mat ye bacha dosri aurat ko de do, yeh zinda tou rhay ga, mere pas na sehi meri ankhon k samne tou rhay ga, moula Ali ne jab yeh dekha tou sab per yeh sabit ho gya k yehi aurat bache ki haqiqi maa thi jab k dosri aurat kh b na boli,
is misal aap samajh jain Rasool Allah ki rehlat k foran baad hi khilafat k liye “ASHAAB” ne saqifaa (rendezvous)ma plan shru kr diya k khilafat ko qabo kro, jab moula Ali aur ahl-e-bait aur onke sachay ashaab Rasool Allah k kafan dafan mai lage hoay thay, aur baki Ashaab ko khilafat ki pari hoi thi, jo Rasol k yaar-e-ghar b thay…LEKIN AFSOS YAR NE APNE YAR KA JANAZA B NA PARHA…
kuch suwal muje b kerne ka haq hai. wese mulla je yeh tou batao Rasool pak s.a.w.w k janaze mai kitne musalman sharik thay???
@Hamid shah, Title “shia” Quran o Hadith ma majood hai Hazrat Ibrahim (as) ko shia naam le ker pukara gya hai, kia tum ise mante ho?
Term “Shia” Asal ma Quran se akhaz ki gai hai is ka actual origin Quran se hai, jis ma Allah ne Ibrahim nabi(as)ko hazrat NUh(as) ka shia kaha hai, aik aur ayt ma 2 admiyo ki larai ka zikr hai jis ma aik Musa(as) ka “shia” tha aur dosra on ka dushman.
1. The Holy Qur’an 37:83
2. The Holy Qur’an 28:15
asal ma logon ko bewekof tou aap logo ne bnaya hoa hai
sadqy g,,,ap ny mairy sawal k jawab ma jo likha ha wo jawab to ne g?phr b ap choonky molaun k hily howy hain maff krna ma molviat sy qoson door bagta hun chalen ap ny jo jawab likha ha iske koe dalil dy dain kaya hazret ali rz ny ya bt kb kahi the kisi kitab sy hawala dy dain ya phr kahen sy b na mily to nahjulbalagha to hazret ali rz k khutbat ka majmoua ha wahan sy dikha dain,ya ilfaz ap sabit kr dain kisi kitab sy k hazret ali rz ny kaha ho k ma khilafet ly sakyta tha pr is waja sy ne lee,agr un sy na mily to hazret hassan rz sy sabit kr do un sy ne hazret hussain rz sy un sy ne zianulabidin sy un sy ne to jafar sadiq sy,imama baqir sy,ali naqi sy,taqi ali sy,mousa kazim sy ,hussan askari sy apny 12 imamon ma sy kisi ka hawala dy kr ya lafz sabt kro k ma khilafat ly sakta tagha maira haq tha pr is waja sy ne lee agr sabit na ho saky r yaqeenan ne to janab ny imam e adil o barhaq fateh khaiber,qatil e marhab shair e khoda ,damad e mustafa as,sayedna ali ul murtaza rz pr jhoot bandah ha bs ya he ibtada ha ap k ghalt moaquf ke pr etyat sy keyon k ap aik mulan ko ne aik aam musilman ko dalil dy ry hain jo ap k din pr iran ma sarkari sata k muqalmon ma hisa ly choka ha
jan ke amaan paun to arz kr sakta hun ap ny hamid shah ko b jawab sahe ne deya sheia katy hain groh ko quran ma aya ha k tum un logon ke tra na ho jana jino ny firqy paida kya r sheia ho gy .kaya is sy murad b ap ka groh he ha?
Itminaan rakhe sab suwalon k juwab do ga apko per aik shart per wo yeh kmai b aap se kuch suwal karon ga, is trah aap guftago ko mazeed uljha rhai hain,
Dekhye nahj-ul-balagha utha ker ‘
imam farmate han yeh 25 saal (pehle 3 khulfa ka door) mere liye is trha thay jaise galley ma phansi hoi haddi jisse na nigal sako aur na ugal sake, ye aik chota sa hawala hai, aur is khutba ka naam “khutba shakshakia” hai arbi ma hai agr aap nehjul balaga se waqfiyat rekhte hain tou dekh lain utha k khud hi,ya postel address dain ma courier kra do ga. mazeed bi hawla dia ja sakta hai, Mashallah aap tou sarkari satah k munazir hain, but bakhuda ma aik aam se student hun jis ne abhi graduation kia hai mai bi koi molvi nhi.
dekhye janab shia ka matlab hai pervi krene wala, kisi k peche chalne wala, ” maslan tashi-e-janaza” lafz suna hai na aap ne yani janaze k peche chalna, ye jo tabir aap bata rhay ho ghalat hai. dekye suwal woh karen jo logical ho plz
chalen g aik bt to ty ho gai k kal ap ny jo ilfaz hazret ali rz ke traf mansoob kya thy wo maazallaha un ke zat e grami pr janab ke traf sy botan tha,inalillahaewaainaelaierajeuun,,,,ya apny ilfaz sabit kren k khilafat maira haq tha r ma ly sakta tha pr is waja sy ne lee jo waja janab ny bayan ke ha?ap ny jo hawala dya ha us pr ma dalil bd ma dun ga ap ny bybunyad hawala paly dya ha lehaza ap jawab b paly dain,,r agr ap wo ilfaz jo ap ny imam e masoom ke trf mansoob kya hain wo na dikhayy kisi khutby sy to janab ko ma qabil e taqalum ne samjta,,,2ousri bt ap ny aaj to likh dya k shia k matlib pervi krna ha zra apny kl k ilfaz daikhen ap ny likha tha k shia k lafz quran sy lya gya ha jis pr ap ny dalil b di k musa as ka shia r ibraim as,ma ny ap ko quran sy btaya k jahan lafz shia ha wahan sy agr ap he murad hain to,,,un logon ke tra na ho jana jino ne farqy paida kya r shia ho gy,,,ya ma ny quran ka hawala dya ha r ap ny kah dya k ya ghalat ha waja bta sakty hain keyon ghalat ha?r agli bt b sunen kl ap ny lafz e shia py jo comments dya thy aaj ap k wo comments ne hain ap apni bt sy istra phisal gy hain jistra molvi…….theak ha g lagy rao lagy rao pr jo ilfaz ap ny imam e masoom ke traf mansoob kya hain wo sabit kr do?ne to phr bt wo he ha paly wali jo ap ko b pta ha?
lagta ha ma b shooka itmanan rakh k he baith jaun kyon k jawab to ha he ne ab ay ga kahan sy waisy ap k ilm ma ezafa kr dun apni kitaben zroor praha kren baly musilmano ke na b paren pr apni to paren ap ke kitaben,kafikuleni,alirshad shaikh mufeed,alamuwaraa,,kashfulghuma arbali,maroujhzahb masoodi,muntaalamaal mirza abas qumi,,hayat ul qaloob mula baqir majlasi in tamam kutab ma likha ha k hazret ali rz sayedna abubakar sadiq rz k dor e khilafet ma qazi ul quzaa k mansab pr ry,,kaya hazret ali ny ghasib hakoomat ka hoda qabool kya tha? dil bara kren r aaj he beharulanwar,muntaalmaqal r muntaalamaal b daikh lain pouchaa gya imam e masoom sy ap ny abubakr ke bait kb ke?jawab dya k ALLAHA R RASOOL K HUKAM KE TAMEEL KE HA….ap ke zat e garami k laya doa he kr sakta hun k khoda tujy kisi tufan sy ashnaa kry ….k tery baher ke mojon ma iztarab ne….ab ap apni books ka inkar kr dain ya koe looli langri taweel paish kren ne to bt wo he ha paly wali r ap ko b pta he ha
@SAJID SHAH
allama shibli nomani ny alintaqad ma likha ha k khoda ke qasam hajaj ny islam k haq ma itni bari bahlaaee ke k iska muqabla ho he ne sakta
===========
Allama Shibli Nomani ny Apni Book Al-Farooq Main, Hadhrat Umar Farooq (RA) ky bary main Hadhrat Fatima (SA) ky Saath jo Kuch Kiya Chalo wo tou Maan Hi Lo Ap…
@Hajjaj Bin Yousuf ky barRy main Allama Moudoudi ki Kitab hi Parh lyn, He Worte ky, Aik Achy Insaan ka Qatl ka, Aik Insaan ki 1,000 Nekiyon ky Barabar nahi ho sakta hai…
Aur Qatl bhi Kin ka, Hadhrat Abdullah Ibn Zubair (RA) Jaisey Sahabi Aur Kaaba per Sang BarRi…
Aur Rahee Baat yazid (LA) ko Support krny ki tou Ahmed Ibn Hanble, Tarikh Tabari Sy ley kr Ibn Kathir ki book, Tarikh Ibn Kathir Parh Lo….
yazid tou phir bhi aik bacha tou Jo yazid ky Walid ny Hadhrat Ali (AS) ko Gaaliyan Di Aur Hadhrat Hassan (AS) ko Zahr Dilwaya, ye Sab kuch Tarikh Ibn Kathir main hai Jao Parho.
Allama Jalaal Ud Din Suyti ki book hi parh lo Ap yazid ky liay Tarikh E Khulfa.
” chalo tum ne imam-e-masoom tou mana moula Ali (as)ko tmri zuban se yeh ilfaz tou nikle jazakallah…wah bai wah dekhen aap jeteay mai hara meri trf se tohfa hai apko 🙂
ma ne koi hawala nhi diya logic se baat ki aur misal de elaborate bi kia tha,
“khilafat maira haq tha r ma ly sakta tha pr”….ye ilfaz mere hain moula Ali k nhi… is k hawala k peche na paro
Amongst the companions Hadhrath Abu Bakr is viewed as the most superior on account of his closeness to the Holy Prophet (saaws). If this is indeed the case then why did the Holy Prophet (saaws) not select him to be his brother when he (saaws) divided the companions in to pairs on the Day of Brotherhood? Rather, the Prophet (saaws) chose Hadhrath Ali (as) saying “You are my brother in this world and the next”, so on what basis is Hadhrath Abu Bakr closer?
See The History of the Khalifahs who took the right way, by Jalaladeen Suyuti,
sahaba ma se abu bakar ko baki ashab se bartari hasil ha k wo Hazoor k bht qareeb ty,agr waqai asa hai tou Hazoor ne abu bakar ko q apna bhai na bnaya (on the day of brotherhood) jabke Hazoor pak ne Ali as ko apna bhai bnaya “aur farmaya Ay Ali tum is dunya mai aur agli dunya ma b mere bhai ho” kis bina per abu bakar ko fazilat hasil hai? dekhain , tarik-e-khulafa by jalaladeen suyuti
khilafat maira haq tha r ma ly sakta tha pr….yeh ilfaz ma ne hazrat Ali k nhi qoute kiye thay, aur na hi ma ne ma yeh ilfaz likhe hain apne comment main, jo ma ne likha woh yeh hai,
(apki baat sehi hai moula Ali agr chahte tou akele hi kafi thay on sab k liye aur apna haq talwar k zor se wasul ker skte thay, per kese aisi hakumat k liye talwar utha sakte thay moula Ali kyun k aap jante thay k yeh log abhi naye musalman hoay hain aur mere is iqdaam se ummat kahin dobara apni pechli halat ma na chali jai, eik waja tou yeh thi. moula Ali jante thay agr jang ki gai tou nouzaida ummat musalma ultay paon na phir jai,)
Agr hazrat Ali 3 khulafa k door ma aham ehdon per faiz rhy, tu ono ne kisi bi jang ma hissa Kyun na liya jo k khulafa k door ma lari gayin? koi tarikh k hawalah hai aapke paas!! khas tor per jihad kufar k khilaf hr musalman per wajib hai…is k baraks Hazrat Ali ne apne door me 50 saal ki umar mai Nehrawan, siffeen o jamal larin?
ap agr itny he zbardast tareekh dan hain gardeezi g to ma ny ali naqvi ko janab k mahzeb ke motabr bokks k hawaly dya hain r ap ke kutab k hawaly kyon dy ra hun uski b waja saf zahir ha k ap un kitabon k elawa dunyan ma r kisi ktab ko manty he ne ab jo mazhb quran pr b kamil emaan na rakhta ho zahir ha wo mahzhb to na howa din howa r jb din howa to phr bt wo he ha ply wali jo ap ko achi tra pta ha waisy akhlaqi tor par ap ko chaya tha ap us nukty pr bt krty k ap k momin bi ny hupr ke guftaguu ma imam e masoom ke traf jhoot banda ha paly uska jawab dain jo k mujy 7 dafa qum k sarkari debates ma b ne mila ap kaya dain gy raty rataay jumly,bybunyad guftaguu,mangharat stories,laayani qisy,bani hoe rawaeten na paishbkren,,ya jo ap hazret ali rz r sayedna ameer e muawiya rz ka ikhtalif byan kr ray hain ya quran ka inkar ha,,apny mahzb k allama kashi ke rijall ka mutalya kren ap k 2 imamon r aik un k commander inchief ny un ke bait ke the,kaya koe aj ka molvi mimber py baith k ap k abu g ko galyan dy phr ap ko kahy mairee bait kro ap kr lo gy?r ap husnain karimain rz ko kis hd tk ly k ja ry hain k uno ny us ke bait ke jo mimber sy galyan daita tha un k walid garami ko ya rijal kashi ka inkar karen ya jhooty qisy chor dain nae to bt wo he ha paly wali r ap ko b pta ha
ap ko alf baa ka b pata ne g paly kaen parh lain phr bt karna ma ny imam e masoom naqs kya ha ma ap ke bt ka kjawab ilzaman dy ra hun ap mafhoom e mukhalif samj gy hahahahahaha sadqy jawan ap ny man lya na k wo ilfaz mairy thy hazret ali k ne? bs phr bt wo he ha jo ap ko paly sy pata ha ma na b btaun to b?
bat wo he hoe na ap ny dobara b wo he ilfaz likhy hain k ma agr talwar uthata ya jang krta to ya nuqsan hota is lya khamosh ra naqvi g ya ilfaz ap k zehn k ikhtarah ha ya ilfaz hazret ali rz k ne ap kyon un ke trf apny jhooty khayalaat ko mansoob krny py baa zid hain ya to hawala paish kren ma ny to allama kashi ke rijaal ka hawala dya ha k hazret ali rz qazi ul quzaa k mansab pr ray ap kah dain k ya ktab hamari nae ha?ya ap allama kashi ka inkar kren ya ap jurat kren r kah dain k hazret ali rz bura b samjty thy pr wazarten b laity thy?apny moaquf pr motahbr hawala dain r allama kashi k hawaly ka jawab dain ma to ap ke kitabon sy bt kr ra hun ma ny quran o hadis ke to bt he ne ke kyon k ap na quran ko manty ho na nabi saws k frman ko agr apni kitaben he parh lo phr b bt ho sakti ha ,,,,un he k matlab ke kah ra hun zaban mairee ha bat un kee….un he ke mahfil sanwarta hun charagh maira ha rat un ke,,,hahahahafil waqt ap r ap ka hawala zer e bas ha ap is pr bt kren agr ha to r agr ne to bt wo he ha paly wali jon ap ko b pata ha?
os kitaab ka reference pora do: reference includes 1.Writer 2.volume 3.page no. jese ma oper de chuka hoon apki kitabon se
ap ke apni motabar r mashoor books k bary ma b maloomat 0 ha sono ma page numb b bta daita hun pr agr wahan sy b maira moaquf sabit ho jy to phr?allama kashi 3rd century ka mustanad shia alim ha uski kitab ha rijal kashi,hussnain kareemain rz r unky commander incheif qias rz ny saydna ameer e muawiya ke na sirf bait ke blky frmaya k ap he hamary bather imam hain,,,,ap ko apni kitab ka name r imam he pta ne?mothrem ap k 2 imam jisy apna imam kah ry hain wo ap k baqole mimber pr baith k hazret ali rz ko naoozbillah galyan daita tha ap k 2 masoomeen aur 1 com ny bait kyon ke wja wo bayan krna jo ap k 2 ono imamon ny bayan ke ho apna khayal paish na krna r agr waja b na mily bait b sabit ho ap ke books sy waz\ifa laina b sabit ho to phr bat wo he ha jo ap ko pta ha mujy kany ke zroorat ne
javed chodri saib ap ne tareekh ka mutaliah nehi kia
Wah bara khoobsorat mazmoon hey laikin aalamgeer aur mehmood Ghazanvi ki Misal kuch theek nahen kion ke Aalm Geer taqreeban 52 saal hakoomat kerta raha aur Mehmood Ghazanvi ney Islami hakoomat ki bunyaad rakhi.
ya zamana andhi taqleed ka ne,taqeeq justajuu r haqaiq janany ka zamana ha mujy yaqeen ha naqvi sb ap daleel k samny aajiz aa gy hain akhlaqi tor par ap ko phr sy apny din pr nazarsani krni chaya inshallah ap is nateejy pr ponchen gy k shia din hazret ali rz sy ly kr husnain kareemain rzsayda fatima rz khatoon e janat r hussan askari tk tamam hasteyon sy mutasadam r unky nazreyat k mukhalif ha agr ap siraat e mustaqeem qabool kr lain yani hazret ali rz ka haqiqi rasta to dunya akhrit ke kamyaabi ha r na kren to bat wo he ha jo ap ko paly sy pata ha mujy kahny ke zroorat ne
Javed Bhai,you have compared good and bad in a very logical way.An evil deed does not give a permanent advantage to a man indulging in it.On the other hand,a good work can live for a longer period and the coming generations remember that deed with envy and admiration.Don’t you think it is a deficiency in our educated people or in our education system that ,majority of our people try to imitate bad people not good one.Also bad deeds are more attractive for their short term advantages than good works.It is something to ponder upon,we should follow long term advantage than short one.Our education system needs reforms to do something in this regard.
Ap bht acha likhty han ,i like your colmn,write and awake our nation.
sultan Mehmood ki age 63 year thi
Naseem Hajazi ki book k mutabiq. sultan bot shikan tha lakin bot farosh nahi tha ap ne usy lalchi bhi kaha jo k ghalat hy.
wo aik naik insan tha us k baray main ap ye mat likho.
Aurangzaib k bary main bhi ap ne kuch aisa hi likha jo k ghalat hy. lagta hy k ap Muslims Heroes k mukhalif ho ap sirf musharaf or Zardari jaison k qabil ho. meri kisi bhi bat ka mind na karain plz.
excellent, aise soch insan me a jay to dunya se zulam be khatam ho jayee
AOA,dear brother best wishes for you and your faimly.I like your colmn.
Eik baat tou bohat hi wazih hai aur woh yeh keh Ahle Tashee tareekhi haqaiq ko hazam karna nahin chahte. Aur jo hazrat dunya se guzar chukay hain un per laan taan kar ke apne aap ko sirat e mustaqqem per samaghte hain.
ch,sab ap ny bilkul baja farmaya.mein to samjhta hn ye or b lamha hy fikria hy hm in misalon sy ni seekhtay
ye isan ke fitrit man shamil ha dolitt ke hawas lakin ye sab kuch krnay se pahlay 1 baar in ko sochna chahe go oupr ravi ne likha ha insan ko nasehat zaror hasil hoti ha